The Power of Emotional Marketing: Why Facts Don’t Convince People

Most people like to believe they make decisions based on logic and facts. But in reality, emotions play a far bigger role than we often realize. Research in behavioral psychology, including Daniel Kahneman’s work on Thinking, Fast and Slow, shows that our brains operate using two systems:

System 1 (Fast Thinking): Intuitive, emotional, and automatic. This system makes quick decisions based on gut feelings and past experiences.

System 2 (Slow Thinking): Analytical, logical, and effortful. This system takes more time to process facts and data before making a decision.

Here’s the catch: most decisions are made by System 1, not System 2. Our emotions and instincts drive our choices, and only afterward do we use logic to justify them.

The Power of Emotion in Decision-Making

1. Emotion Creates Connection

Have you ever made a purchase because something felt right? That’s System 1 at work. Whether it’s choosing a brand, a coach, or a career move, emotions like trust, excitement, or even fear guide the initial choice.

Facts matter, but they come second. If a message doesn’t create an emotional connection, people are less likely to engage with it—even if the information is valuable.

2. Stories Activate System 1 Thinking

Facts tell, but stories sell. That’s because stories engage our emotions, making information more memorable and persuasive. Neuroscientific studies show that when we hear a compelling story, multiple areas of our brain light up, creating a deep, lasting impact.

For example, instead of saying, “80% of clients see improvement in six months,” a coach could share a story: “Sarah came to me feeling stuck in her career. Within six months, she landed a leadership role she once thought was out of reach.”

Which one resonates more? The story. Because it triggers emotion and paints a picture of transformation.

3. People Buy Feelings, Not Products

When people hire a coach, they aren’t just paying for sessions—they’re investing in confidence, clarity, and transformation. They’re not buying coaching; they’re buying a better future they can feel.

This applies to every decision. People don’t buy a car just because of horsepower and fuel efficiency—they buy the feeling of freedom, status, or security that comes with it.

How to Use Emotion in Your Message

If you want to influence decisions (ethically), you need to tap into emotions.

Here’s how:

• Lead with feelings, not features. What does your audience truly desire? Confidence? Relief? Hope? Speak to that first.

• Tell compelling stories. Case studies, personal experiences, and relatable scenarios engage emotions far more than data alone.

• Use vivid, sensory language. Instead of “reduce stress,” try “imagine waking up energized, free from the weight of constant anxiety.”

• Create a sense of belonging. People want to feel understood and part of something bigger. Show them they’re not alone in their struggles and that change is possible.

Remember This: Emotion First, Logic Second

We often think we make decisions with logic, but it’s emotion that moves us. Facts can support a decision, but they rarely spark action on their own. If you want your message to land, make people feel something first. The logic will follow.

Looking for brand and content strategies delivered to your inbox? Join the community here, it’s free.